What is the Analysis of Impediment to Fair Housing?
The Analysis of Impediments (AI) to Fair Housing Choice provides an overview of laws, regulations, conditions, and other possible obstacles that may affect an individual’s or household’s access to housing and is prepared for the purpose of implementing fair housing rules to affirmatively further fair housing.
The County of Alameda, as lead agency, together with multiple participating jurisdictions—the cities of Alameda, Albany, Berkeley, Dublin, Emeryville, Fremont, Hayward, Livermore, Newark, Oakland, Piedmont, Pleasanton, San Leandro, Union City and Unincorporated Alameda County; the housing authorities for the cities of Alameda, Berkeley, Livermore, and Oakland; and the Housing Authority of the County of Alameda—have formed a regional collaborative for the purpose of completing an Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (Regional Analysis of Impediments). This Regional Analysis of Impediments helps to meet the partners’ obligation to affirmatively further fair housing, which is a requirement of recipients of funding from the US Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). HUD requires that an analysis of impediments be conducted every five years, preferably in conjunction with a five-year Consolidated Plan process.
The AI identifies fair housing barriers and actions that the County and its partners will take to overcome historic patterns of segregation, promote fair housing choice, and foster inclusive communities that are free from discrimination.
What are the Impediments to Fair Housing in Alameda County?
The 2025-2029 AI report identified the following nine impediments to fair housing in Alameda County:
- Residents, homebuyers, and property owners have insufficient understanding of fair housing requirements and protections. Analysis indicates that continued outreach and enforcement is needed to educate property owners, tenants, and those in the lending market about rights and obligations around fair housing protections and potential discriminatory practices.
- Discriminatory barriers prevent tenants from accessing housing opportunities. Fair housing laws offer protections for those with protected characteristics, however, data shows that people still experience discrimination despite these protections - particularly based on disability, race, and source of income. Further, some characteristics are not protected by law and are the most cited areas of discrimination, including criminal background, eviction history, and credit history. These barriers may prevent people from accessing housing in areas that offer the opportunities they may be seeking.
- The region lacks the number of affordable housing units needed to meet the demands of low to moderate income households. Consistently, throughout consultation stakeholders and the public cited the lack of affordable units as the number one barrier to housing opportunity. Analysis of the cost of housing show significant increase in home values and the rental marketing making it increasingly difficult for renters to find units they can afford and for residents to achieve homeownership.
- Property turnover is resulting in displacement of residents and high costs of housing leave few options accessing new housing that is safe, decent, affordable, and near opportunity areas. As property values climb, more property owners look to sell their units to realized profits. When landlords sell properties with tenants residing in them, tenants face possible displacement due the units turning over from rental units or because of increasing rent costs. Community members cited displacement as a major impediment to accessing jobs close to home and maintaining connections that are rooted in community.
- Increasing rent costs are pushing residents out of communities where they wish to live and where they have connections to support systems and opportunity. As rents increase, renters are forced to move farther from amenities to find affordable housing costs. The result of this displacement is difficulty in accessing jobs, reaching needed services, and increases in transportation costs in lieu of housing costs.
- The region lacks the accessible units and supportive housing units needed to meet the demands of special needs households. While affordable housing is lacking in general, accessible affordable housing is even more scarce. According to community stakeholders, those with physical disabilities and supportive housing needs are the most difficult to house.
- Increasing rent costs have disparate impacts on special needs households that tend to have fixed incomes and fewer options for housing that accommodates their needs. Individuals with fixed incomes are the most vulnerable in areas with significant affordability challenges. As housing costs and other costs of living rise, their fixed incomes often see no or little increases making them most at risk for homelessness. Households with fixed incomes include seniors and people with disabilities.
- Systems feel disjoined and hard to navigate for people seeking affordable housing options and access to opportunities. Community residents expressed concerns about the inability to navigate systems that might provide support for their housing and other basic needs. They often do not know where to start or do not have the means to navigate the process of follow up, documentation requirements, access to transportation to make appointments, and other logistics required to secure assistance, especially when they are already facing homelessness or struggling to maintain their housing.
- Significant housing challenges require coordinated approaches to meeting the needs of communities. As a region, Alameda County has many resources that serve its residents. However, the challenges to meeting the needs of low- and moderate-income people as well as people with special needs while simultaneously addressing discrimination are significant. To make the most impact on the barriers to housing opportunity, a coordinated approach is needed.
To address these impediments, the following regional goals developed to create a cohesive strategy and leverage resources:
Goal #1 |
Promote fair housing enforcement and education through interagency collaboration. |
Goal #2 |
Address challenges of displacement among residents in high cost and gentrifying areas. |
Goal #3 |
Continue to support the creation of new affordable housing opportunities. |
Goal #4 |
Expand housing opportunities for people with special needs. |
Goal #5 |
Enhance coordination across jurisdictions to promote collaboration in meeting regional challenges. |
To view the entire report and the actions each jurisdiction identified they would take, click here.